Hired Mourners and Dirge Singers
In the ancient world, families often hired professional women to mourn loudly at funerals. These skilled mourners knew the traditional songs and wailing patterns that expressed grief. They would lead the community in mourning. When Jesus arrives at Jairus's house and finds flute players and a noisy crowd, these are hired mourners.
Professional mourning women (*meqonenot*, literally "those who lament") were hired to lead the communal mourning at funerals in ancient Israel and throughout the ancient Near East - skilled practitioners of lament whose performance of grief articulated the community's sense of loss and facilitated the deceased's proper transition to the realm of the dead.
Archaeological Evidence
Depictions of professional mourners appear extensively in Egyptian tomb paintings. New Kingdom tomb paintings at Thebes regularly show rows of women with hands raised, hair loosened, and bodies bent in formalized grief postures beside the mummy and coffin. These are professional mourners, not family members, distinguishable by their positioning and formalized gesture vocabulary. At Megiddo, an ivory carving depicts a funerary feast with female attendants whose postures suggest mourning roles. Greek black-figure pottery (6th-5th century BCE) depicts the *prothesis* (lying-in-state) with women performing the formalized lament gestures that professional mourners used. Terracotta mourning figurines found in various Mediterranean archaeological contexts represent the professional mourner as a religious-cultural type.
Biblical Passages
Jeremiah 9:17-20 provides the most explicit biblical reference: "This is what the LORD Almighty says: 'Consider now! Call for the wailing women to come; send for the most skillful of them. Let them come quickly and wail over us till our eyes overflow with tears and water streams from our eyelids.' The sound of wailing is heard from Zion: 'How ruined we are! How great is our shame! We must leave our land because our houses are in ruins.' Now, you women, hear the word of the LORD; open your ears to the words of his mouth. Teach your daughters how to wail; teach one another a lament." The reference to teaching daughters the skill confirms it was a professional craft transmitted in family lineages. Mark 5:38-39 records hired mourners (*threnountas*) already present and "weeping and wailing" at Jairus's daughter's death - Jesus's dismissal of them with "the child is not dead but asleep" thus disrupted a formal professional service.
Dead Sea Scrolls Evidence
The Qumran community's mourning regulations in the Damascus Document (CD) and community rules address proper mourning behavior, though they do not specifically discuss hired mourners. The Hodayot (Thanksgiving Hymns, 1QH) contain elaborate lament poetry that may reflect the community's own mourning practices, possibly drawing on the professional lament tradition as a literary resource. The community's separation from mainstream society likely affected their relationship to professional mourning practices, which were part of the broader public religious life they had withdrawn from.
Parallel Cultures
Professional mourning women appear across virtually all ancient Near Eastern and Mediterranean cultures. In Mesopotamia, the *kalu* (lamentation priest) and *kezertum* (female lamentation specialist) were temple professionals specializing in communal and funerary lament. Sumerian lament literature (*Lament for the Destruction of Ur*) represents institutionalized communal mourning at the highest literary level. Egyptian professional female mourners (*drt*) appear in tomb paintings and mortuary texts as standard elements of the funeral. Greek *góoi* (lament songs) performed by professional women at funerals were a recognized literary and social form analyzed by Plutarch and other classical authors. Roman *praeficae* (hired female mourners) are described by Varro and appear in various Roman literary sources - the practice was explicitly criticized by Cicero and banned at certain points, reflecting its ubiquity.
Scholarly Sources
Saul Olyan's *Biblical Mourning: Ritual and Social Dimensions* (2004) is the essential modern treatment. Kathleen O'Connor's commentary on Jeremiah in the Westminster Bible Companion addresses the professional mourners passage. For the Egyptian evidence, John Taylor's *Death and the Afterlife in Ancient Egypt* provides comprehensive coverage. For Greek and Roman parallels, Margaret Alexiou's *The Ritual Lament in Greek Tradition* (2002, revised ed.) is the landmark study. Gary Anderson's *A Time to Mourn, A Time to Dance* contextualizes lament within biblical religious practice broadly.
Modern Misconceptions
A common modern misconception treats hired mourners as a form of hypocrisy or performative grief without genuine emotion. Ancient sources suggest the professional mourners' performance served a communal function: giving voice to grief that the bereaved family might be too overwhelmed to express, and creating a sonic and physical environment of mourning that facilitated the community's collective processing of loss. Another error assumes Jesus's dismissal of the mourners in Mark 5 was a critique of professional mourning as a practice; it was rather a claim about the girl's condition that made their service premature - his statement was about her status (sleeping, not dead), not about the legitimacy of their profession.
- ISBE: Mourning
- Freeman, Manners and Customs of the Bible, pp.416-419
- Matthews, Manners and Customs of the Bible, pp.300-302
References
- Orr, J. (ed.) (1915) The International Standard Bible Encyclopedia. Chicago: Howard-Severance Company. [Public Domain]
- Josephus, F. (c.94) The Works of Flavius Josephus (trans. W. Whiston). [Public Domain]
- Philo of Alexandria (c.40) The Works of Philo (trans. C.D. Yonge). [Public Domain]
- Category
- 🪦 Burial & Mourning
- Period
- JudgesMonarchyDivided-kingdomSecond TempleNew Testament
- Region
- CanaanJudahIsraelGalilee
- Bible Passages
- 5 verses
Read the full International Standard Bible Encyclopedia article on this topic.
Read ISBE Article